Oats edge out wheat for most people: about 4 g of soluble beta-glucan per 100 g and a low GI porridge. Wheat has more total fibre. Side by side table inside.
.avif)
In short
From Vively member data
2.1 mmol/L
Typical rise after porridge
across 458 members, more than white bread at 1.8
2.5 mmol/L
Typical rise after Weet-Bix
the highest of the oat and wheat foods compared
52%
Rose 2 mmol/L or more
after porridge, while 18% rose less than 1
For most people, oats are slightly healthier than wheat, mainly because of their soluble fibre. Rolled oats carry about 4 g of beta-glucan per 100 g, the soluble fibre linked to lower LDL cholesterol, while wheat has less than 1 g. Traditional rolled oat porridge is also low GI (51 to 57), while most everyday wheat foods, such as bread and wheat biscuits, test 64 to 78. Wheat has its own strengths: whole wheat has more total fibre (11.4 g against 9.5 g per 100 g) and less fat and fewer kilojoules. And the form matters as much as the grain. Instant oats tested 82 to 87, while ordinary wheat pasta tested 44 to 50.
Below is a side by side comparison per 100 g, then the GI of the oat and wheat foods you actually eat. After that, we explain why your own glucose response can differ from what the tables predict.
Figures are from the FSANZ Australian Food Composition Database (uncooked), except beta-glucan, which isn't in that database. GI values are from the University of Sydney GI database, for a common food made from each.
| Per 100 g | Rolled oats | Whole wheat grain | Wholemeal flour | White flour |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Energy | 1,564 kJ | 1,362 kJ | 1,371 kJ | 1,479 kJ |
| Protein | 12.2 g | 11.2 g | 11.6 g | 10.0 g |
| Fat | 9.5 g | 2.4 g | 1.6 g | 1.3 g |
| Total fibre | 9.5 g | 11.4 g | 8.8 g | 2.2 g |
| Beta-glucan (soluble fibre) | about 4 g | under 1 g | under 1 g | under 1 g |
| Available carbs | 54.5 g | 58.3 g | 61.6 g | 73.2 g |
| Iron | 3.5 mg | 3.4 mg | 2.8 mg | 1.2 mg |
| GI of a common food | 51 to 57rolled oat porridge | 48 to 56boiled wheat kernels | 64 to 78 | 70 to 74white bread |
As Dr Michelle Woolhouse, Vively's Medical Director, explains: "The other thing fibre does, is it slows down the uptake of glucose in the system, and gives the body time to adjust to the glucose load and feed the cells the energy they need. Fibre is also good for the gut bugs, good for making healthy stools (ie detoxification of waste products) and it has the added benefit of making us feel fuller for longer. All good things!"
No. Oats and wheat are different cereal plants. Oats don't contain gluten in the way wheat does. They contain a related protein, avenin, which Coeliac Australia says most people with coeliac disease tolerate, although a small number react to it.
Oats sold in Australia can't be labelled gluten-free, because Australian and New Zealand food law doesn't allow it. Ordinary oats are often contaminated with wheat during growing and milling. If you have coeliac disease, talk to your medical team before adding oats, and choose specially produced uncontaminated oats if they say yes.
Here's how the oat and wheat foods you're likely to eat compare on GI, lowest first. All are Australian tests unless noted.
So the healthier choice for blood sugar is the less processed one: rolled or steel-cut oats over instant, and pasta, grainy bread or whole kernels over fine-flour bread and flakes. If you have diabetes, the NDSS lists traditional rolled oats and steel-cut oats among lower GI breakfast cereals. Talk to your doctor or dietitian before changing your carbohydrate intake, especially if you take insulin or medicine that can cause lows.
Oat flour is milled whole oats, so its nutrition is close to rolled oats (the FSANZ database doesn't list it separately). It has no gluten network, so it won't rise on its own, and bread recipes usually replace only part of the wheat flour with it.
Most "oat" breads on the shelf are wheat bread with some oats added. The ones with a published GI tested lower than plain wholemeal: Burgen Oat Bran and Honey at 49 and Vogel's Honey and Oats at 55 (1995), against 64 to 78 for wholemeal. A wheat loaf with lots of whole grains or seeds, such as Burgen Wholemeal and Seeds (39), can test lower still. Our low GI flour guide ranks more flours.
A GI test feeds about 10 healthy people a fixed amount of carbohydrate from one food, on its own, after an overnight fast, and averages the results. Your breakfast has milk, fruit or honey, and a portion that's your own. People also respond differently to the same bowl, depending on sleep, stress, activity and metabolism. A GI number is an average, and you're not an average.
Our members' continuous glucose monitor (CGM) data shows how far real responses can sit from the lab numbers. Porridge has a low GI in the tables, yet it didn't come out lowest in everyday use.
Typical rise in blood sugar (mmol/L) with each food logged on its own by Vively members wearing a continuous glucose monitor. Each food has at least 130 members behind it.
GI tables come from lab tests on small groups. Real responses vary a lot from person to person. See the curves on our glucose spikes page, or try a CGM to see your own.
This is real-world app data, not a lab test. Portions weren't measured, and someone may have eaten something they didn't log. The members don't have type 2 diabetes. See the full curves on our porridge and Weet-Bix glucose response pages.
Lab tables can't tell you whether porridge or toast suits you better. A Vively CGM can: eat each breakfast on a different morning and compare the curves in the app. Our guide to blood sugar after eating explains what the numbers mean, and our shredded wheat guide compares the wheat biscuit cereals.
Wear a Vively CGM and compare your own curves after different breakfasts.
Slightly, for most people. Oats have about 4 g of beta-glucan per 100 g against under 1 g in wheat, and rolled oat porridge is low GI (51 to 57). Whole wheat has more total fibre and fewer kilojoules.
No. Oats and wheat are different cereal plants. Oats don't contain wheat gluten, but they are often contaminated with wheat, and in Australia they can't be labelled gluten-free.
Traditional rolled oat porridge tested 51 to 57 and steel-cut oats 48 to 53, while instant oats tested 82 to 87. For wheat, pasta tested 44 to 50, wheat biscuits 68 to 69 and white bread 70 to 74.
Rolled or steel-cut oats are a good lower GI breakfast, and the NDSS lists them as such. Wheat pasta and grainy breads are good lower GI choices later in the day. Ask your dietitian how much carbohydrate suits you.
Neither is clearly better. Oats have more kilojoules per 100 g (1,564 against 1,362 for whole wheat) because of their fat, but beta-glucan may help you feel full. Portion size and what you add matter more.
Often, if it's a genuine oat bread. Burgen Oat Bran and Honey tested GI 49 and Vogel's Honey and Oats 55, against 64 to 78 for wholemeal. Check the ingredients, because many oat breads are mostly wheat flour.
Per 100 g uncooked, rolled oats have 1,564 kJ, 12.2 g protein, 9.5 g fat, 9.5 g fibre and 54.5 g available carbs. Whole wheat has 1,362 kJ, 11.2 g protein, 2.4 g fat, 11.4 g fibre and 58.3 g available carbs (FSANZ).
The Baseline Health Check is a blood test covering 70+ markers at one of 3,700+ collection centres. Your dietitian goes through your results with you and builds your plan. $99 a month, no minimum term.